Article

Name: “Tolstoys are Totally Different Matter...” A. K. Tolstoy in Bunin’s Experience of Historical Reflection: B. Genre Aspect of the Theme of Memory

Authors: E. E. Anisimova

Siberian Federal University Krasnoyarsk, Russian Federation

In the section The Plot in the System of Cultural Universals: Bunin, East and West of the Russian Emigration

Abstract:

The article deals with I. A. Bunin’s perception of the personality and works by A. K. Tolstoy. The key components of this reception are the system of philosophy of history views formulated by A. K. Tolstoy and his concept of historical memory. The belonging of the 19 th century poet to the large Tolstoy family was mythologized by Bunin and became a reason for understanding and determining the young writer’s own position in relation to each of the three writers: L. N. Tolstoy, A. K. Tolstoy and Bunin’s contemporary A. N. Tolstoy. The paper draws upon fictional and nonfictional documents by I. A. Bunin and A. K. Tolstoy.

Bunin’s reception of the personality and artistic heritage by A. K. Tolstoy was determined by the history of his origin. The Tolstoy family attracted Bunin’s attention because it was an illustration of his own concept of the literary gift as a “family affair”. Leo Tolstoy enjoyed an undisputed genius and generally recognized family reputation. Aleksey N. Tolstoy’s biography, on the contrary, was ambiguous – the fact that inspired Bunin’s scandalous hints in his essay “The Third Tolstoy”. Aleksey K. Tolstoy’s biographical path of was also surrounded by similar rumors – but Bunin in his article “Inonia and Kitezh” prefers to keep silent on them. In the 1900s, A. K. Tolstoy appeared to Bunin as a rival poet, and in the eyes of Bunin’s contemporaries as the one of his main literary predecessors. Bunin’s poem “Kurgan” was a kind of poetic response to A. K. Tolstoy’s ballad “Kurgan” dedicated to the problem of historical oblivion. These works-doublets could serve as an illustration of one of the types of literary “revision” introduced by H. Bloom. Bunin developed the plot of A. K. Tolstoy’s “Kurgan” in the elegiac genre and demonstrated the value of the past in the present. Since 1918, Bunin’s perception of Tolstoy’s legacy has changed. A. K. Tolstoy’s views of the Russian history are publicly emphasized in the “Cursed Days”, “Mission of the Russian Emigration” and “Inonia and Kitezh”. According to A. K. Tolstoy, the historical catastrophe for Russia was programmed by “Tatar yoke”, which distorted the European character of the national culture and personality and later drove the nation to the particularly Asian, as Tolstoy thought, phenomenon of Ivan the Terrible. Borrowing some modern ideas from the natural sciences, Bunin transferred a number of A. K. Tolstoy’s observations into an anthropological sphere and pointed out specific signs of the “Mongolian” traces in Bolsheviks’ Russia.

Keywords: I. A. Bunin, A. K. Tolstoy, philosophy of history, memory, genre, ballad, anniversary article

Bibliography:

Anisimov K. V. Kniga I. A. Bunina “Vospominaniya” kak tsikl: opyt rekonstruktsii avtobiograficheskogo syuzheta. Kritika i semiotika [Critique and Semiotics], 2011, no. 15, p. 143–163. (in Russ.)

Atamanova E. T. Russkaya literatura XIX veka v kontekste khudozhestvennoy prozy I. A. Bunina: problema reministsentsiy [Russian literature of the 19th century in the context of I. A. Bunin’s fiction: the problem of reminiscences]. Cand. Philol. Sci. Diss. Elets, 1998, 246 p. (in Russ.)

Averin B. V. Dar Mnemoziny: romany Nabokova v kontekste russkoy avtobiograficheskoy traditsii [The gift of Mnemosyne: Nabokov's novels in the context of the Russian autobiographical tradition]. St. Petersburg, 2003, 399 p. (in Russ.)

Bloom H. Strakh vliyaniya. Karta perechityvaniya [The Anxiety of Influence. A Map of Misreading]. Ekaterinburg, 1998, 352 p. (in Russ.)

Bunin I. A. Poems. In 2 vols. St. Petersburg, 2014, vol. 1, 541 p. (in Russ.)

Bunin I. A. Pis’ma 1905–1919 godov [Letters from 1905–1919]. Ed. by O. N. Mikhaylov. Moscow, 2007, 829 p. (in Russ.)

Bunin I. A. Pis’ma 1885–1904 godov [Letters from 1885–1904]. Ed. by O. N. Mikhaylov. Moscow, 2003, 768 p. (in Russ.)

Bunin I. A. Publitsistika 1918–1953 godov [Journalism of 1918–1953]. Ed. by O. N. Mikhaylov. Moscow, 1998, 640 p. (in Russ.)

Bunin I. A. Okayannye dni. Vospominaniya. Stat’i [Cursed days. Memories. Articles]. Moscow, 1990, 416 p. (in Russ.)

Bunin I. A. Collected works. In 6 vols. Moscow, 1987–1988. (in Russ.)

Dolgopolov L. K. Na rubezhe vekov. O russkoy literature kontsa XIX – nachala XX v. [At the turn of the century. About Russian literature of the late 19 th – early 20 th century]. Leningrad, 1985, 352 p.

Fedorov A. V. Lichnost’ i tvorchestvo A. K. Tolstogo v vospriyatii I. A. Bunina. In: Tvorcheskoe nasledie I. A. Bunina: traditsii i novatorstvo [I. A. Bunin’s creative heritage: traditions and innovation]. Oryol, 2005, p. 33–36. (in Russ.)

Gnedich P. P. Kniga zhizni. Vospominaniya. 1855–1918 [Book of life. Memories. 1855–1918]. Moscow, 2000, 368 p. (in Russ.)

Koshelev V. A. Mudrost’ neumestnogo: Zhizn’ i tvorchestvo A. K. Tolstogo. Literatura v shkole [Literature at school], 1995, no. 1, p. 26–34. (in Russ.)

Kotelnikov V. A. Aleksey Konstantinovich Tolstoy v zhizni i v literature. In: Tolstoy A. K. Complete collection of poems. In 2 vols. St. Petersburg, 2016, vol. 2, p. 7– 172. (in Russ.)

Lirondelle A. Le poète Alexis Tolstoï, l’homme et l’oeuvre. Paris, 1912, 677 p.

Masanov I. F. Slovar’ psevdonimov russkikh pisateley, uchenykh i obshchestvennykh deyateley [Dictionary of pseudonyms of Russian writers, scientists and public figures]. In 4 vols. Moscow, 1957, vol. 2, 388 p. (in Russ.)

Nikolaev D. D. Parizhskoe “Vozrozhdenie” 1920-kh gg. o Sergee Esenine. Chast’ pervaya: ot Bunina k Khodasevichu (1925–1926). Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Ser. 9. Filologiya [Moscow State University Bulletin. Series 9. Philology], 2015, p. 20– 38. (in Russ.)

Novikov V. I. Aleksey Konstantinovich Tolstoy. Moscow, 2011, 289 p. (in Russ.)

Reytblat A. I. Letopisets slukhov (Neopublikovannye vospominaniya V. P. Burnasheva). Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie [New Literary Review], 1993, no. 4, p. 162–174. (in Russ.)

Tolstoy A. K. Complete collection of poems. In 2 vols. St. Petersburg, 2016. (in Russ.)

Ustami Buninykh [Through The Bunins]. Dnevniki Ivana Alekseevicha i very Nikolaevny i drugie arkhivnye materialy. In 3 vols. Ed. by M. Grin. Frankfurt am Main, 1977–1982. (in Russ.)

Vasiliev V. K. Syuzhetnaya tipologiya russkoy literatury XI–XX vekov (Arkhetipy russkoy kul’tury). Ot Srednevekoviya k Novomu vremeni [Russian Russian literature plot typology of the 11 th – 20 th centuries (Archetypes of Russian culture). From the Middle ages to Modern times]. Krasnoyarsk, 2009, 260 p. (in Russ.)

Yurchenko L. N. I. A. Bunin v svete esteticheskikh traditsiy A. K. Tolstogo i K. N. Leontieva. In: Tvorcheskoe nasledie I. A. Bunina: traditsii i novatorstvo [I. A. Bunin’s creative heritage: traditions and innovation]. Oryol, 2005, p. 30–33. (in Russ.)

Zhemchuzhnikov M. Legenda o proiskhozhdenii grafa Aleksey Konstantinovicha Tolstogo. Illyustrirovannoe prilozhenie k gazete “Novoe vremya” [Illustrated Supplement to the newspaper “Novoe Vremya”], 1911, no. 12820, 19 Nov. (2 Dec.), p. 6–7. (in Russ.)

Zhukov D. A. Aleksey Konstantinovich Tolstoy. Moscow, 1982, 383 p. (in Russ.)